You bought your commercial property policy years ago and have renewed it every year since without much of a second look. That’s normal, and it’s also how a lot of Nova Scotia businesses end up underinsured without realizing it. If your building or shop’s insured value hasn’t kept pace with what it would actually cost to rebuild today, a clause buried in most property policies, called coinsurance, can cut your claim payout by roughly the same percentage you’re short, even on a loss far smaller than the building’s full value.

What a Coinsurance Clause Actually Does
A coinsurance clause is an agreement built into most commercial property policies. Your insurer sets a required percentage of your property’s full replacement value, usually 80%, 90%, or 100%, and you agree to insure to at least that level in exchange for a lower rate than an unconditional policy would cost. Replacement value, what it would actually cost to rebuild or replace the property today, not what you paid for it or what it’s assessed at for property tax, is the number the whole clause runs on. Fall short of the required percentage, and the shortfall becomes your problem on every claim, not just a total loss.
How Does the Penalty Actually Work?
Rob de Pruis, the Insurance Bureau of Canada’s national director of consumer and industry relations, lays out the math plainly in a Canadian Underwriter report on the issue. Take a building that should be insured for $1 million but only carries $700,000 in limits. That’s insured to 70% of its value. On a claim, the insurer pays 70% of the loss, not the full repair cost. A $100,000 kitchen fire or burst-pipe claim pays out $70,000, not $100,000. De Pruis is blunt about the misunderstanding: a lot of business owners assume a loss smaller than their policy limit is simply covered in full. “That’s not correct,” he says. The required percentage on your own policy, 80%, 90%, or 100%, changes the exact math, which is one more reason to ask your broker what number actually applies to you instead of assuming.
Why More Nova Scotia Businesses Are Underinsured
This isn’t a one-time mistake most businesses make and move past. De Pruis points out that since 2019, consumer inflation has risen just over 20%, while rebuild costs in some areas have climbed more than 80% in the same stretch. A policy updated to keep pace with inflation alone is still falling behind what a contractor would actually charge to rebuild. Skilled-trades shortages add to it, both pushing labour costs up and stretching out how long a rebuild takes. Lockton Canada’s October 2026 market update adds tariffs to the list, naming steel, aluminum, and lumber among the sectors already affected, and recommends reviewing property values whenever a business changes materially, not just waiting for the next renewal date to come around.
Why Doesn’t This Show Up Until a Claim?
Because most people don’t go looking. The Insurance Bureau of Canada’s own consumer information centre fields about 25,000 inquiries a year, and a good share of them are business owners asking whether their coinsurance penalty sounds right, usually right after a loss, when it’s too late to fix. A commercial real estate owner who last updated a building’s insured value a decade ago has this exposure sitting quietly on every policy renewal since. A contractor who bought a shop full of tools and equipment five years ago and never revisited the number carries the same gap on the contents side.

It’s Not Just the Building, Either
The same blind spot shows up in business interruption insurance, the coverage that replaces income you lose while you can’t operate after a covered loss. Many commercial policies default to a 12-month benefit period, and the Insurance Bureau of Canada says that’s often not long enough. A serious rebuild, especially with today’s material and labour delays, can run 18, 24, or even 36 months. A business that assumes its income is protected for as long as it takes to reopen may be just as underinsured on that piece as it is on the building itself.
What to Actually Do This Week
- Get a current replacement-cost valuation for your building and contents, not the purchase price and not the number from your last renewal.
- Ask your broker exactly what coinsurance percentage your policy requires, 80%, 90%, or 100%, and whether your insured value actually clears it.
- Check how many months of business interruption coverage you carry, and ask whether 18 or 24 months fits your situation better than the default 12.
- Update your insured value any time you renovate, expand, or add equipment, not just when a renewal notice lands.
- Review the whole policy every year, not only after a loss forces the question.
- If rising material costs have hit your industry specifically, say so when you call your broker instead of assuming it’s already priced in.
I’m Rayanur Rahman, and I check the insured value on every policy I remarket at renewal, not just the premium, because a cheaper quote built on an old building number doesn’t actually fix anything. I’d rather tell a Halifax business owner their coinsurance number is off now than have them find out from a reduced claim payout. That review is part of what’s behind my services page, not just the quote that comes after.
The Bottom Line
A coinsurance clause isn’t a trick insurers use to avoid paying claims. It’s the other half of the deal you made when you bought the policy, and it only becomes a problem once the insured value stops matching what it would actually cost to rebuild. That number moves every year, even when nothing about your business changes. Check it before a loss forces the question, not after.
When Did You Last Check Your Insured Value?
If it’s been a while since anyone updated what your building or shop is insured for, I’ll go through the numbers with you before they matter at claim time.
About the author. Rayanur Rahman is a commercial insurance broker with Western Financial Group in Bedford, Nova Scotia. He places commercial policies for restaurants, contractors, trucking and transportation companies and commercial property owners across the Halifax Regional Municipality, with access to the standard Canadian insurers and to specialty and MGA markets. He’ll read through an existing policy and say plainly whether its insured value and coinsurance requirement still line up, before a claim is the one testing it. Reach him at 902-321-1712 or book a 30 minute call.
Sources: Canadian Underwriter: ITV gap widens as co-insurance clauses catch businesses off-guard. Insurance Business Canada: Tariffs are making insured values out of date, Lockton Canada warns. Insurance Bureau of Canada: Rise in catastrophic weather events exposes issues with underinsurance for many businesses. Photo by Point3D Commercial Imaging Ltd. on Unsplash. Photo by Barn Images on Unsplash. General information only, not advice on your specific policy. Check your own wording.

Leave a Reply